Split from X-Rebirth Steam poll thread - Round 2

General discussions about X Rebirth.

Moderator: Moderators for English X Forum

Slashman
Posts: 2525
Joined: Tue, 12. Oct 10, 03:31
x4

Post by Slashman »

quick brown wrote:
perkint wrote:
quick brown wrote:Perhaps you yourself or possibly someone else who champions your pro-steam cause should take the time to create a thread (with mod permission)
I suspect the mods stance will still be that the Steam debate remains in the one thread. It has been attempted before and any thread about Steam (and a specific poster attempted it in more or less any thread :p ) will end up with the same repeated debate :(

Tim
I know, I follow this debate with great interest.

It's a shame though. Without such facts posted cleanly this thread may well reach another 100 pages.

I live in hope that the FACTS about adopting steam can be posted cleanly against the FACTS of not adopting it.
I think that the problem is that this started as a poll...which then lead to the discussion of Steam.

If this had started as points for and against in a concise and level-headed manner, it might have more use.

The thing is that because of the poll(and its results), people jumped in and started decrying Steam...this lead myself and some others to point out errors(as we saw them) and that lead to responses from some of the non-Steam folks and it snowballed from there.

It got heated on either side. Some pro-Steam responses were bone-headed, I admit. But when you have people on the other side trying to make the point that Steam is violating human rights and using conspiracy theories, I'll be the first to say it annoys me no end.

Not because I love Steam so much, but because I hate misinformation.
If you want a different perspective, stand on your head.
Alan Phipps
Moderator (English)
Moderator (English)
Posts: 31794
Joined: Fri, 16. Apr 04, 19:21
x4

Post by Alan Phipps »

There would be no objection at all if TTD as the originator of the thread were to be pursuaded to edit his opening post to include the 'factual' bullet points of the arguments both for and against in a brief and non-emotive manner. Whether he would wish to do so and whether you would all wish him specifically to arbitrate as to what is considered 'factual' are unknowns.

The chances of another pro/anti Steam debate or poll thread being allowed to take place are needless to say quite negligible.
A dog has a master; a cat has domestic staff.
Shugreid
Posts: 30
Joined: Sat, 29. Oct 05, 20:18
x3tc

Post by Shugreid »

I tried Steam I dont Like it.
Why do I need Steam to play an offline game.
Why does Steam put extra Software on my computer.
Other companies download minus the extra Software.
My 100k download speed although not great is thankfully not the worst.
I could give Sky a hard time here about charging me for UP TO 20 meg Broadband but this Thread is about whether or not I want to use Steam.

I Dont!

Is this a conspiracy or misinformation?

The Thunderious Slience from Egosoft as to the DVD request must end Soon?
Slashman
Posts: 2525
Joined: Tue, 12. Oct 10, 03:31
x4

Post by Slashman »

Shugreid wrote:I tried Steam I dont Like it.
Why do I need Steam to play an offline game.
Why does Steam put extra Software on my computer.
Other companies download minus the extra Software.
My 100k download speed although not great is thankfully not the worst.
I could give Sky a hard time here about charging me for UP TO 20 meg Broadband but this Thread is about whether or not I want to use Steam.

I Dont!
And I can't argue against that. You don't want it. You've tried it.
If you want a different perspective, stand on your head.
User avatar
EmperorJon
Posts: 9378
Joined: Mon, 29. Dec 08, 20:58
x3tc

Post by EmperorJon »

Indeed.
______
I'm Jon. I'm mostly not around any more. If you want to talk, please message me! It's cool.
______
MrRixter
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed, 28. Dec 11, 02:23

Post by MrRixter »

Over 5 million Pc gamers on steam at the moment and over 30 million active accounts enjoying a great service. Steam experiences double digit growth every year. It's the way forward and you guys against it are a tiny tiny insignificant minority. Embrace it or forget about playing your favourite Pc games and find another hobby. Maybe you should go buy a console and join the cool kids talking gangsta online playing corridor shooters that turn your brain into mash. After going through that installing steam will look like a walk in the park.
Nova Scotia
Posts: 253
Joined: Fri, 16. Jun 06, 13:24
x3tc

Post by Nova Scotia »

Just about ready leave for the Bretonia system (Freelancer Crossfire 1.9 :)

Hopefully when I return there will be some good news or news that settles the matter.Worst case ,will still be somewhat good.I won't have to upgrade my pc for XRebirth ,Like I did for Reunion and TC but than that would be sad as well ,it as been a long love with the X series that will come to an end.

Freelancer 1-1
:lol:
Peanutrulz
Posts: 54
Joined: Thu, 28. Aug 08, 04:03
x3tc

Post by Peanutrulz »

I find steam at this point as a necessary evil. I use them because i have to not because i want to.

Yes they have amazingly good sales and prices but at what cost? I dont know actual numbers but alot of the time i think steam is actually getting more of the sale price of the game then the people that put there sweat and tears into making the game. And i think many would agree making an actual game is alot harder then managing a server network.

Of course they have to fund and support a what i would imagine to be a very large network of expensive servers and staff and of course they have to make a profit.

But steam has the Digital purchase industry by the throat no other client, impulse, d2d, gamersgate can compete.

The recent status of all current games after steam has become this popular is lets just say the quality has taken a nose dive these last years. To tie this to steam would be pure speculation so im not going to get into that. This link is coincidental, i personally dont know if this is true or not so plz dont call me out on this i really dont know...

On a side note Steamworks scares me to no end. I have a feeling this is going to be a major turning point in the entire modding community.


To answer the poll ill re state. I will use steam for X rebirth because i have to not because i want to. Im not going to boycott a game i am really looking forward to because they decide that steam is required thats kinda crazy. Im not happy about it but dosnt look like i have a choice.
User avatar
EmperorJon
Posts: 9378
Joined: Mon, 29. Dec 08, 20:58
x3tc

Post by EmperorJon »

Well when you think about, game development companies and publishers do have a choice, and Steam also reduces cost in terms of distribution. I doubt the figures are that bad.

As for the nosedive in quality of games, I don't think it has anything to do with Steam or Digital Distribution. I'm not quite sure what is causing it. Indeed, there seem to be markets willing to buy utter crap these days, which makes it easier to produce said utter crap and sell it than to make a real game.

There are certain companies (one particular one begins with an e and end with an a... ahem.) that I have not considered buying games from in a significant amount of time after the quality of their work plummeted through the floor.
______
I'm Jon. I'm mostly not around any more. If you want to talk, please message me! It's cool.
______
Peanutrulz
Posts: 54
Joined: Thu, 28. Aug 08, 04:03
x3tc

Post by Peanutrulz »

I would be interested to see what steams cut is. I dont think those numbers will ever be published.

But the recent sale on AP what did it cost 3$ ... how much did ego see of that 3$ ?
Deleted User

Post by Deleted User »

MrRixter wrote:Over 5 million Pc gamers on steam at the moment and over 30 million active accounts enjoying a great service. Steam experiences double digit growth every year. It's the way forward and you guys against it are a tiny tiny insignificant minority. Embrace it or forget about playing your favourite Pc games and find another hobby. Maybe you should go buy a console and join the cool kids talking gangsta online playing corridor shooters that turn your brain into mash. After going through that installing steam will look like a walk in the park.
This is entirely the kind of crap I mentioned previouslly.
dougeye
Posts: 2409
Joined: Sat, 7. Mar 09, 18:29
x3tc

Post by dougeye »

with respect to steam putting a program on your computer...

if you are someone who uses / creates mods for x game you probably at one time or another have installed an extra program for that purpose, plugin manager for example, whos to say one of these programs is any more or less damaging to your computer? the difference with steam being it collects data so it can try and make the user experience better, for example interenet connection type and speed, granted if you basicly dont have internet then there is not much that can be done. I have never had any random 3rd party emails or promotions etc through letting steam run on my pc.

and also ill get slated for saying this but saying that because you live in an area with bad interenet means that egosoft should go out of its way to produce a disc version is sort of like saying that you live in an area without electricity and egosoft must produce a version of the game that ships with its own generator so you can power your pc to play it!

im not trying to attack any particular posters but what im saying is if a company decides on a course of distribution and it happens to be that some users are unable to purchase and play the game then thats life unfortunatly, yes it would be nice to have a choice but sometimes you dont get a choice.

I also strongly think that Rebirth will come on disc, in fact im almost certain as english stores have had it on there forthcoming lists for months. Once installed from a disc it should only take a small amount of updating and steam updating before you can play the game as a steamworks title, if you dont want the updates then dont dial up your connection when using steam, also if downloading updates is a problem due to connectivity would you also expect egosoft to release update cd/dvd roms for people who are unfortunate enough not to have decent internet?
I used to list PC parts here, but "the best" will suffice!
Slashman
Posts: 2525
Joined: Tue, 12. Oct 10, 03:31
x4

Post by Slashman »

quick brown wrote:
MrRixter wrote:Over 5 million Pc gamers on steam at the moment and over 30 million active accounts enjoying a great service. Steam experiences double digit growth every year. It's the way forward and you guys against it are a tiny tiny insignificant minority. Embrace it or forget about playing your favourite Pc games and find another hobby. Maybe you should go buy a console and join the cool kids talking gangsta online playing corridor shooters that turn your brain into mash. After going through that installing steam will look like a walk in the park.
This is entirely the kind of crap I mentioned previouslly.
On that we can agree.

I'll just count it as a drive-by troll or something.

Peanutrulz wrote:I would be interested to see what steams cut is. I dont think those numbers will ever be published.

But the recent sale on AP what did it cost 3$ ... how much did ego see of that 3$ ?
I've heard the going rate is 30% of each sale. That's actually a good deal less than a DVD Retail cut would net Egosoft.

In any case, that hardly matters so much as the fact that no manufacturing costs are incurred for each digital copy sold. There's a reason why some companies, like Paradox, have said that they now consider doing no retail releases. You don't have to shell out the initial upfront cost of producing discs and material.

Egosoft is slightly bigger than some other devs...so they do retail discs, but still use digital distribution.

Consider this though: Every game has die hard fans that buy on release. If a game is retail only, it rapidly looses steam(no pun intended) in terms of sales until it eventually hits bargain bin status. Some games hit it quicker than others. Bargain bin prices though, get determined by the retailer...not Deepsilver/Egosoft. They've already sold the copies in the store, and it's bargain bin, no fresh copies are going to be ordered...and definitely not at the initial price.

With Steam or another digital retailer, you're 'producing' endless copies for sale. Even if your price drops and with Steam taking a cut, you make direct profit from each digital copy sold. Even if Steam were taking 60% instead of the predicted 30%, its money that you make without any additional manufacturing costs.

When a holiday sale rolls around and Steam requests that you allow them to put your game on sale, you might make less per sale, but people flock to games on sale like flies on ****.

That's how I ended up noticing TC at all. I may have only paid $14 for it, but I'd likely have never bought it without noticing the sale and asking some guys on Bluesnews.com if it was a good game.

There is a reason publishers and small devs are gung-ho about digital distribution. In addition to the initial sales push of a new release...your game can continue to produce revenue long after you've released your last patch for it.

Most people have a limited budget when it comes to buying full releases(usually only so many per year), but that budget goes out the window when a game is marked down and offered as a digital sale. I know a guy on Bluesnews who has 1134 games on his Steam list. Needless to say he didn't buy all those at full retail(but he does spend a huge amount on games).

I've also seen sales of a game continue to be strong after its sale period ended(presumably word of mouth etc.).

It's a big mistake to think that Deepsilver/Egosoft are looking to lose money with this move. It may well be that the sales of X games on Steam over the past couple of years has lead them to this point. All that is pure speculation on my part, of course. I don't have any inside info.
Last edited by Slashman on Mon, 2. Jan 12, 22:48, edited 1 time in total.
If you want a different perspective, stand on your head.
User avatar
EmperorJon
Posts: 9378
Joined: Mon, 29. Dec 08, 20:58
x3tc

Post by EmperorJon »

I just ignored him. Best to leave things alone.
______
I'm Jon. I'm mostly not around any more. If you want to talk, please message me! It's cool.
______
Jumee
Posts: 2893
Joined: Sat, 29. Oct 11, 20:19
x3tc

Post by Jumee »

TEKing66 wrote:After trying Steam and failing miserably trying to get a Steam game installed (yes, because of my lowly dial-up connection). And contacting every ISP that might be able to provide me with a better option to access the internet (only to be told that they DO NOT service my area).

What other option do I have other than hoping that a Steam free version of the game will be made available?

I have the Superbox and so could get X3AP for free, if I could get it downloaded. But, Steam is telling me that to download 1 Gig of data is going to take me 50 days (this of course assumes that my connection doesn't get broken during that time).

In the end, I really don't care how I get any game. But I do care about getting it in a timely fashion and being able to play it without have to connect to the internet as I DO NOT care to play games online. Simply want to play a single player game without being restricted by another piece of software or my internet connection.

Yes, I understand that this is DS and(/or) Ego's decision to go to Steamworks. And I understand the benefits for Egosoft. Unfortuneately for me it is a decision that will be leaving me out and behind. The plain simple fact is that I can not get broadband and so find Steam to be useless in my circumstance. And, for me, a DVD with a Steam based game is essentially just an expensive paperweight. I would like to play X3AP and Rebirth just as I have played all games in the X series to date. Will I get to? It isn't looking to be the case. Does anyone but me care? Probably not. Have I accpeted that I may never get to play the new X games? Yes at this point I have! Does that make it any easier to swallow that fact? No, not in the least.
I know this is a pretty stupid advice but could work as a last resort:
is there anyone you could ask to download AP for you? than I think you can just copy it to steam folder and than it should just install it without re-downloading. It might work as many people just copied their none-steam TC to a steam folder to install AP over it without having to download 7 extra GB. If this works then turn Steam to offline mode immediately after installation is finished (with very slow internet even opening the store page can cause some "lags") and only turn it back online when a patch is out and you want to download it, hopefully none of the patches is going to be too big
Shugreid
Posts: 30
Joined: Sat, 29. Oct 05, 20:18
x3tc

Post by Shugreid »

“the difference with steam being it collects data so it can try and make the user experience better”
You sound like the Steam sales rep. You don’t really believe that, do you?
If that’s your answer then I will give Steam an even wider berth.
My 100k Internet is not great but doable, have some thought for those that want an offline game available offline. Not all progress is good. But if you are giving away free generators, I want one.
By the way I only play Vanilla but have no objection to modders, some end up in the game anyway and make it better.
Vanilla to me is a simple question of competing against the computer inside the programmers parameters and trying to achieve the set goals.
On this thread we are trying to get Egosoft to distribute minus Steam, what is the problem with that.
You like Steam I don’t, simple.
At a guess over 90% of anti Steam posts were a response to Why don’t you want Steam.
My son thinks Steam is great I don’t, we don’t argue about it.
All I want is a DVD for first choice or another downloader who does not want to add an extra program to better my experience.
I have downloaded all my patches from Egosoft so far, Its not broken why fix it.
Sorry shutting up now.
User avatar
perkint
Posts: 5191
Joined: Wed, 6. Nov 02, 20:31
x3tc

Post by perkint »

dougeye wrote:and also ill get slated for saying this but saying that because you live in an area with bad interenet means that egosoft should go out of its way to produce a disc version is sort of like saying that you live in an area without electricity and egosoft must produce a version of the game that ships with its own generator so you can power your pc to play it!
That's a daft analogy. People are asking for an option that is the same as Egosoft have done in the past, especially X3TC. Not an absurd request such as your suggesting! :evil:
dougeye wrote:I also strongly think that Rebirth will come on disc
We know it will, but it will still be a SteamWorks bound game.
dougeye wrote:would you also expect egosoft to release update cd/dvd roms for people who are unfortunate enough not to have decent internet?
No, the people who don't want Steam are hoping Egosoft may be persuaded to offer download from their site (again, as previous games) which you can download from anywhere and stick on USB (or whatever) without needing to download it on the gaming PC, signed in to Steam.

Tim
Struggling to find something from the forums - Google it!!! :D
strude
Posts: 1471
Joined: Wed, 3. Aug 05, 08:15
x4

Post by strude »

Peanutrulz wrote:I would be interested to see what steams cut is. I dont think those numbers will ever be published.

But the recent sale on AP what did it cost 3$ ... how much did ego see of that 3$ ?
Why do you care? It seems people who ask this question expect to look like the altruistic white knight, with deep concern over Egosoft's bottom line.

The arrangement between Steam and Egosoft regarding Egosoft's cut of sales is irrelevant. We have no idea what that figure is, except for hearsay and rumours. Even those are based on other titles which may have no impact on this, as each title may be negotiated individually. Additionally, Egosoft (or DS) would have entered into the arrangement with Steam, fully aware of the implications to their profits from sales. They couldn't have been too concerned with it, given that they effectively told people to wait for the sale. So why should players be concerned over Egosoft's balance book?

Egosoft's cut of game sales is solely between Steam and Egosoft/DS, and is of no relevance to us players. We have no need to concern ourselves with that issue, nor anywhere near enough information to even make it a consideration.
Gaming PC: Gigabyte H270M-D3H | i7 7700 | 16Gb DDR4 | Gigabyte GTX1060 6Gb OC | Asus Xonar DGX | Window 10 Home 64bit | Samsung 256Gb SSD
User avatar
NUKLEAR-SLUG
Posts: 2372
Joined: Thu, 4. May 06, 13:20
x3tc

Post by NUKLEAR-SLUG »

Jumee wrote:
TEKing66 wrote:After trying Steam and failing miserably trying to get a Steam game installed (yes, because of my lowly dial-up connection). And contacting every ISP that might be able to provide me with a better option to access the internet (only to be told that they DO NOT service my area).

What other option do I have other than hoping that a Steam free version of the game will be made available?

I have the Superbox and so could get X3AP for free, if I could get it downloaded. But, Steam is telling me that to download 1 Gig of data is going to take me 50 days (this of course assumes that my connection doesn't get broken during that time).

In the end, I really don't care how I get any game. But I do care about getting it in a timely fashion and being able to play it without have to connect to the internet as I DO NOT care to play games online. Simply want to play a single player game without being restricted by another piece of software or my internet connection.

Yes, I understand that this is DS and(/or) Ego's decision to go to Steamworks. And I understand the benefits for Egosoft. Unfortuneately for me it is a decision that will be leaving me out and behind. The plain simple fact is that I can not get broadband and so find Steam to be useless in my circumstance. And, for me, a DVD with a Steam based game is essentially just an expensive paperweight. I would like to play X3AP and Rebirth just as I have played all games in the X series to date. Will I get to? It isn't looking to be the case. Does anyone but me care? Probably not. Have I accpeted that I may never get to play the new X games? Yes at this point I have! Does that make it any easier to swallow that fact? No, not in the least.
I know this is a pretty stupid advice but could work as a last resort:
is there anyone you could ask to download AP for you? than I think you can just copy it to steam folder and than it should just install it without re-downloading. It might work as many people just copied their none-steam TC to a steam folder to install AP over it without having to download 7 extra GB. If this works then turn Steam to offline mode immediately after installation is finished (with very slow internet even opening the store page can cause some "lags") and only turn it back online when a patch is out and you want to download it, hopefully none of the patches is going to be too big
Yes, for someone in TEking66's situation with a dial-up connection this would work perfectly well. Download the files you need, transfer them onto USB and copy them onto your machine and then authenticate with the Steam servers before going offline.

Obviously this is a far from ideal solution, but for someone with little or no net access it would still allow them to play.
Shugreid wrote:“the difference with steam being it collects data so it can try and make the user experience better”
You sound like the Steam sales rep. You don’t really believe that, do you?
If that’s your answer then I will give Steam an even wider berth
Yes, we do. Happy customers are return customers and return customers are good for business. You think Egosoft have supported their previous games with numerous patches and free content downloads for purely altruistic motivations?
Peanutrulz wrote:I would be interested to see what steams cut is. I dont think those numbers will ever be published.

But the recent sale on AP what did it cost 3$ ... how much did ego see of that 3$ ?
Doesn't matter. Steam do not get to decide what price they can sell another publishers game for so any promotion that was run was done so with Egosoft/Deepsilvers agreement so they evidently decided it was worth it to them.

(Personally I think AP was just Egosoft testing the water for future paid DLC.. but that's a whole different thread..) :P
Slashman
Posts: 2525
Joined: Tue, 12. Oct 10, 03:31
x4

Post by Slashman »

Shugreid wrote:You sound like the Steam sales rep. You don’t really believe that, do you?
If that’s your answer then I will give Steam an even wider berth.
Actually, the fact that you find it hard to believe is rather interesting.

When I take my car in for a service, the motor company calls me the next day or day after to ask me to complete a survey about my experience.

When you purchase or use a service like Steam(with millions of users), that approach wouldn't be feasible since most people find it tedious to fill out that info by themselves...and some people are incapable of doing so.

The hardware/software opt-in survey would be a pretty good way to get information on what OSes are most popular, what hardware is most popular etc. I'd imagine that people developing games would like to know what OSes, video cards, processors and other software are most likely to run alongside their games.

Steam collecting that data would be a good place to start for a developer. I believe CD Projekt said they used similar data when designing the engine for The Witcher 2.

So yeah...maybe they are using it to plot the downfall of the human race...or maybe they're trying to make it easier for developers to taylor their games to the largest market segment. And maybe that kind of method is what makes them more successful than Impulse, D2D, GOG and Gamersgate put together.
If you want a different perspective, stand on your head.

Return to “X Rebirth Universe”