[Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

This forum is the ideal place for all discussion relating to X4. You will also find additional information from developers here.

Moderator: Moderators for English X Forum

vvvvvvvv
Posts: 1363
Joined: Tue, 28. Nov 23, 15:38
x4

[Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by vvvvvvvv »

Please modify the message to include who is being attacked by whom, along with ship codes. This will also allow easier debugging of the infamous reputation death spirals.

Explanation:

I was minding my own business in ZYA-controlled, Family Nhuut, trying to cap a Xenon B in Chimera. I eventually succeeded at 2% hull remaining on B, claimed it personally personally, sat in pilot seat, headed towards Split Wharf in Zyarth Dominion IV to repair it. Half way to the gate in nearly dead B, I receive a comm of a split screaming "Please stop this attack immediately!", several times. Then there's sector dialogue, and then I lose one reputation. +24 becomes +23. What?

So. I go into journals, try to figure out what happened, and the only information is this:
Image

Which is not helpful. I find hostile Mamba in Zyarth Dominion IV, where I was heading.... except I have no ships in the sector. There's also angry police ASP at the gate, but no mention of interdiction in logs. So I'm deeply confused, and don't know what the heck happened. Did police mistake me for xenon or decided to blame me for past attacks of B ship? Because before I captured it, it was chasing a small ship and blew it up. The messages of attack popped up shortly after I began piloting the ship.

So, problems:
* I do not see a code of offended ship in the log. Who is angry at being attacked?
* I do not see who attacked the ship in the log.

Suggestions:

* Alter the message format to "Zya Police Mamba (XYZ-123)" and "Reason: Unauthorized Attack of Shipname1(ABC-456) by Shipname2(XYZ-123)".
* Also, requests to stop attack should be logged into journal in form of "Stop attack requested by XYZ-123" for player ship.

I'm not sure why it isn't already being done. I have a save with angry Mamba in it, but the whole thing is deeply confusing.
Alan Phipps
Moderator (English)
Moderator (English)
Posts: 31815
Joined: Fri, 16. Apr 04, 19:21
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by Alan Phipps »

You are not alone and this has been a frequent request theme for ages, such as example threads here and here.

One of them even had a dev bugtracker number [#1454] but I suspect the devs were looking for a game fault situation rather than a lack of presented information in-game at the time.
A dog has a master; a cat has domestic staff.
Haro
Posts: 21
Joined: Mon, 28. Dec 15, 03:17

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by Haro »

Feature request:
Allow us to contact their faction representative and send an apology. :lol:
- Herbig Haro
vvvvvvvv
Posts: 1363
Joined: Tue, 28. Nov 23, 15:38
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by vvvvvvvv »

Haro wrote: Sun, 22. Sep 24, 18:39 Feature request:
Allow us to contact their faction representative and send an apology. :lol:
There's supposedly a way to apologize in the game, except it is extremely elusive. People claim it is possible to apologize to squad leader with a crown.

In this particular scenario, however, it was unclear who was being attacked, by whom and where. I suspect the game blamed me for previous misdeeds of Xenon B.
Jar B
Posts: 350
Joined: Tue, 18. Jan 05, 14:07
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by Jar B »

vvvvvvvv wrote: Sun, 22. Sep 24, 19:21 There's supposedly a way to apologize in the game, except it is extremely elusive. People claim it is possible to apologize to squad leader with a crown.
That's interesting. All I've ever got was a "I'm not talking to you!"
vvvvvvvv
Posts: 1363
Joined: Tue, 28. Nov 23, 15:38
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by vvvvvvvv »

Jar B wrote: Mon, 23. Sep 24, 16:20
vvvvvvvv wrote: Sun, 22. Sep 24, 19:21 There's supposedly a way to apologize in the game, except it is extremely elusive. People claim it is possible to apologize to squad leader with a crown.
That's interesting. All I've ever got was a "I'm not talking to you!"
I also only ever got that, but NPCs apologize for firing at ME, and people are pretty adamant that this mechanism exists. I think you can talk to a hostile ship after you haven't damaged it for some time.
User avatar
Duncaroos
Posts: 719
Joined: Wed, 4. Jan 12, 22:23
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by Duncaroos »

Alan Phipps wrote: Sun, 22. Sep 24, 10:30 You are not alone and this has been a frequent request theme for ages, such as example threads here and here.

One of them even had a dev bugtracker number [#1454] but I suspect the devs were looking for a game fault situation rather than a lack of presented information in-game at the time.
Don't forget about meeeeeee :rant: :roll: :lol:

Fellow replied this one as well viewtopic.php?f=146&t=459438. Far too often is this brought up
Playing X4+All_DLC on:
CPU: Ryzen 5 5600X; RAM: 4x8GB DDR4 3200MHz; GPU: GTX 1070 8GB, Driver v536.23, DirectX 12.0; OS: Win10 Home 22H2 (19045.4780); Monitor: Single Acer S232HL 1920x1080

Duncaroo's Empire Logistics Tool (v0.23 Beta) - {{Vanilla Economy - Direct link}} {{Economy Overhaul Mod Version - Direct link}}
Alan Phipps
Moderator (English)
Moderator (English)
Posts: 31815
Joined: Fri, 16. Apr 04, 19:21
x4

Re: [Feedback, FeatureRequest] "Unauthorized Attack" notification

Post by Alan Phipps »

Yep, that's why I quoted just two and called them examples of frequent requests. :)
A dog has a master; a cat has domestic staff.

Return to “X4: Foundations”